There are actually two quite distinct categories of appliances that we can consider when we’re looking for the best juicer for tomatoes.
Thus, it’s up to you to decide which would suit your needs best. You’re the one to know what you want to make tomato juice for.
The first category is represented by juicers. These are centrifugal or masticating juicers. These are models like the ones I recommended when I wrote about the best juicer for beets or the best juicer for pineapple.
If we decide to buy centrifugal or masticating juicers that’s because we want to make juice for drinking and that’s about it.
Although, I guess we could use a centrifugal juicer if we want to make not very large quantities of tomato juice for canning, as well.
And that’s how we ended up talking about the second category of appliances that can be used to make tomato juice.
These are actually called tomato strainers. Tomato strainers can be either manual or electric.
The manual ones look pretty much the same like the tomato strainers our mothers or grandmothers used to use. They’re classic and I love them.
We would choose tomato strainers as options for the best juicer for tomatoes if we want to make tomato juice, tomato sauce, tomato paste, etc. from large quantities of tomatoes.
Of course, you might decide to buy both a juicer for your daily juice and a tomato strainer for canning if you want to make your own tomato products for the winter.
Another fruit that can also be juiced by quite different appliances or methods is grapes. So, check out my reviews for the best grape juicer if you are curious to see what those methods are.
Table of Contents
Best Juicer for Tomatoes Reviews
Since we’re here looking for the best juicer for tomatoes, I’m going to assume that people are mainly looking for a juicer to make juice daily from a variety of ingredients or simply a tomato juice for drinking or for a Bloody Mary, for a tomato granita, a gazpacho, soups, for chili, to spice up our rice, etc.
Thus, my focus will be on recommending centrifugal and masticating juicers that can juice tomatoes very well, with maximum yield, without leaving a very wet pulp behind.
However, the thing with looking for juicers for tomatoes it’s that it’s pretty hard finding good ones. Some will not juice tomatoes and other soft fruits (melons) well. It’s going to be a challenge to find some amazing tomato juicers in the centrifugal and masticating categories.
If the pulp is too wet, juice it a second time.
On the other hand, if you want a thicker consistency, juice it just once.
My favorite picks for the best juicer for tomatoes are: Hamilton Beach Juicer Machine, Ninja JC151 NeverClog Cold Press Juicer, 2nd Generation, Breville Juice Fountain Plus Juicer.
However, I’m also going to review a couple of strainers for those who want to make tomato juice for canning in pretty big quantities.
Even a manual tomato strainer can easily handle 100 pounds, 200 pounds or more in a matter of hours or days. An electric strainer needs only 1 hour for 330 pounds (150kg) of tomatoes.
I’m definitely a fan of strainers.
We can also use a blender to make tomato juice but the advantage of a juicer is that it removes both the seeds and the skins. A tomato strainer also removes the seeds and the skin. A blender doesn’t. You’ll need to use a strainer to get a smooth consistency.
1. Hamilton Beach Juicer Machine: Overall the Best Juicer for Tomatoes
If we take the time to read some reviews concerning how the Hamilton Beach Juicer Machine handles juicing tomatoes, we’ll come across some interesting info that will demonstrate why I consider this centrifugal model to be my favorite pick for the best juicer for tomatoes.
The user manual also includes a recipe called Liquid Fire made with 1 medium tomato, 1/2 jalapeno pepper, 1 handful parsley, and 1/2 cucumber. It’s great if you like a bit of spice in your drinks. That’s sure to wake us up better than a coffee.
Of course, if you want to can a lot of tomato juice or sauce, then I recommend looking for a tomato strainer, either manual or electric.
How it juices tomatoes
On the other hand, if you just want to go through a few pounds of tomatoes at one time, then the Hamilton Beach Juicer Machine is capable of handling that really quickly and efficiently.
One buyer mentions that this juicer very quickly dispatched 3 pounds of tomatoes in just a few minutes. However, we are warned that if we have sensitive ears, it might give us a headache to pull through 10 pounds of tomatoes.
Yes, centrifugal juicers like the Hamilton Beach Juicer Machine are notorious for being noisy and they are.
On the other hand, if you read reviews for most masticating juicers, which are the type that are famous for being a lot less noisy but slower, you’ll discover that some people mention that those masticating models aren’t very good for juicing tomatoes and melons.
If you absolutely want a masticating model that won’t break the bank and has the chance to be very decent, then I recommend the Ninja JC151 NeverClog Cold Press Juicer, 2nd Generation.
If you don’t feel that this Hamilton Beach is for you and you have a much more generous budget, then I recommend the Breville Juice Fountain Plus Juicer.
Other buyers mention that they have juiced carrots, beets, cucumbers, celery, tomatoes, apples, pears, broccoli (it has a bit of an overpowering taste so I use it in very small quantities), peaches, plums, and grapes.
Buyers mention that everything tastes great and the unit is very easy to use. Even beginners will be able to handle it without inconveniences.
If the pulp in the pulp container is too wet, you can juice it a second time.
As I’ve mentioned above, the Hamilton Beach Juicer Machine is a powerful juicer that can go through more than a few pounds of tomatoes in a very short amount of time.
The 800 watts motor guarantees that it moves fast, it can handle a wide array of ingredients, including soft fruits and leafy greens, and it’s quite the accomplished juicer.
Well, it’s noisy so that’s one obvious con.
And I love that we get a 3 inch extra-wide feed chute so most tomatoes don’t even have to be cut into big chunks, especially plum tomatoes. Beefsteak might have to be cut into 2 or 4. Just throw your tomatoes down the chute and push them with the included temper.
However, there are some buyers that mention that smaller pieces get juiced better.
What it lacks is a juice container. You’ll have to use your own jars or glasses or whatever container you can find.
Nevertheless, the price under $100 is quite tempting for a lot of us. Not everyone can spend $200-$500 on the best juicer for tomatoes.
And I decided to keep prices under $200 for the three juicers I review here: Hamilton Beach, Brevilla, and Ninja.
The most expensive recommendation is the Omra Spremy Electric Tomato Strainer, which costs around $300 but it also handles more than 300 pounds of tomatoes in an hour. It’s a true beast.
But if you want to make daily juices with all kinds of ingredients and you have a budget strictly under $100, I don’t think there’s a better choice for the best juicer for tomatoes than the Hamilton Beach Juicer Machine.
You can also store the juice for up to 24 hours in the fridge. But I recommend consuming it as soon as you can.
Where to Buy?
2. Breville Juice Fountain Plus Juicer
They’re both centrifugal juicers so they’re both very powerful, quite fast, and quite efficient, while being very noisy.
However, the difference is that this Breville is more than twice more expensive than the model from Hamilton Beach.
I am well aware that, while some people are totally focused on looking for affordable appliances, there are other people who don’t like buying some of the cheapest appliances in any niche, thinking that they might not be good enough or they might not last long enough. Both are common points of view.
If you are interested in a more expensive pick as the best juicer for tomatoes, I recommend the Breville Juice Fountain Plus Juicer.
How it juices tomatoes
Most people really love it. It comes with more than a few negative reviews but I am totally satisfied with the percentage of 5-star reviews that it has.
Frankly, juicers in general, whether they’re centrifugal or masticating, seem to have a high percentage of negative reviews that is generally a bit too high for my tastes.
However, I am satisfied with the percentages that the Breville Juice Fountain Plus Juicer has received.
One buyer mentions that their best results are when they put hard fruit on the bottom, packed the greens in mixed with a juicy fruit like pineapple, orange, tomato or lemon, and then they put a hard carrot or celery on top. It seems that this technique works for them in obtaining the most juice with the least pulp.
It seems that most users prefer to include tomatoes among a number of other ingredients.
Well, if you want to make pure tomato juice, you can definitely use the Breville Juice Fountain Plus Juicer for that alone, as well.
But using a combination of ingredients is always nicer if we make our daily drink.
Overall, the Breville Juice Fountain Plus Juicer is definitely a top pick as the best juicer for tomatoes if you can afford the price.
It comes with a pretty big pulp container and a fairly big juice container.
If the pulp is too wet, I recommend juicing it a second time.
The 850 watts motor is very powerful so expect this Breville to be quick but also expect it to be noisy. At least it can handle pounds of ingredients very quickly.
It comes with a food pusher.
The wide 3 inch feed chute can fit whole fruits and vegetables. It can certainly fit whole tomato varieties. However, there are users who consider that smaller pieces are juiced more efficiently, leading to a higher yield.
It also comes with a stainless steel titanium reinforced micro mesh filter basket. It is designed for optimum juice and nutrient extraction.
We also get 2 speeds. Try the lower speed for tomatoes, first. The low speed is used for soft fruits, including berries, peaches, grapes, etc. And for leafy greens.
Try the higher speed for hard veggies and ginger.
There are instructions in the user manual that contain all the info we need.
Their website also contains a lot of recipes. We get categories for: cookers, food prep, grills, presses & toasters, juicers & blenders, ovens, air fryers & microwaves., and specialty appliances. If you need inspiration, you’ll find it there. There’s even a recipe for Bloody Mary.
Where to Buy?
3. Kitchen Crop Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250
So, let’s review the Kitchen Crop Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250.
It is a manual strainer, like the kind our mothers and grandmothers used to use when they wanted to can hundreds of pounds of tomatoes.
It can certainly handle as many pounds as you’ve got, as long as someone keeps turning on the crank.
Frankly, operating a manual tomato strainer is not tiring at all. We don’t have to use force when we’re turning the handle. And we don’t even have to turn it fast for it to work.
The whole operation isn’t all that tiring, it’s just tedious if you have to do it for hours.
The good news is that a manual strainer is easy to use, easy to assemble, easy to clean, and easy to store.
However, the Kitchen Crop Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250 can be actually turned into an electric strainer if you desire and you’re willing to pay a bit extra.
It’s absolutely an amazing tomato strainer. And it comes with some surprises.
We can make all the great sauces, purees, juices, and jams that we love without painstaking peeling or coring. It’s versatile so let’s discover more.
First of all, I love the stainless steel screens. These are high quality screens that will last for years to come and won’t rust.
It also includes a standard spiral that is 6-¾ inches long. And an instruction manual.
The large hopper and food pusher is also very nice.
Tomatoes are juiced without skin and seeds fairly quickly, just keep turning the handle in a steady manner.
The extended waste spout it’s also very nice. The yield is also good.
It’s very easy to install because it comes with a strong clamp. It has a good grip, which is important because it will keep the Kitchen Crop Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250 from moving around when we’re turning the handle.
If you want to transform it from a manual model into an electric one, there is an option.
You can buy the Optional No-Crank Motor VKPMOTOR.
It is a motor for food strainer and grain mill, it is compatible with VKP250, VKP1025, VKP1248. However, this motor has about the same price as the strainer so we’re doubling the price if we buy the optional motor.
More than a tomato strainer
The Kitchen Crop Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250 comes with an apple/tomato screen with 1.3mm holes. As the name suggests, this is used with apples and tomatoes to make sauces, juices, jams, etc.
However, there are a few other screens that we can buy separately if we want to use it on other fruits.
We get the salsa screen for tomatoes, onions, and peppers.
There’s also the pumpkin screen if you’re a very big fan of pumpkin pie.
And the berry screen to create jams and jellies from berries of all kinds.
Plus, I should also mention that we can also buy a grape spiral separately.
The grape spiral is used with fruits and vegetables with larger seeds like grapes. It is 5.25 inches long. So we can also make grape juice with the Kitchen Crop Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250.
There are many buyers who are using it for canning tomato juice but also for making grape juice and for making pumpkin pie or berries jam and jellies, applesauce, salsa, etc.
A user did juice from 100 pounds of Concord grapes with this manual tomato strainer.
Overall, the Kitchen Crop Johnny Apple Sauce Maker Model 250 is a serious contender for the best juicer for tomatoes title with a very affordable price under $100. And the possibility of buying all kinds of accessories that extend its use and versatility.
Where to Buy?
4. Ninja JC151 NeverClog Cold Press Juicer, 2nd Generation
I must say that I think it would definitely work for tomatoes as well as it does for carrots, beets, pineapple, celery, ginger, leafy greens, cucumbers, etc.
If you want to go through a couple of pounds of tomatoes to make a pasta sauce, I believe that the Ninja JC151 can handle that amount.
The point is that it can handle a small amount of tomatoes but it might be too slow to handle bigger quantities in a timely manner.
So, it’s definitely great for smaller quantities of ingredients. And it can help you make delicious juices with tomatoes and many other ingredients.
We must also consider that this is also one of the cheapest masticating juicers at the moment.
As I’ve already mentioned, I didn’t want to review expensive masticating models like the ones from Omega or Tribest because I don’t believe that they will handle tomatoes all that well.
On the other hand, the Ninja JC151 NeverClog Cold Press Juicer, 2nd Generation is absolutely affordable enough that we can take a chance on it if we have a budget under $150.
One of the main things I really love about this Ninja is the design. This is one of the prettiest juicers that I’ve ever seen.
I also love its small size. I love that it’s tiny and that it can fit even in smaller kitchens and it can be stored in small places. It’s compact and that’s not something we can often say about juicers in general.
The feed chute is pretty small. We’ll have to cut our ingredients into pretty small chunks, which wasn’t the case with any of the above options, neither the juicers nor the manual strainer.
However, if you don’t mind a bit of fruit and veggie cutting, you’ll do great.
It’s very easy to clean and to use.
The pulp and juice containers are pretty small but they match the overall size of this affordable masticating juicer.
Another thing that I like is that we get two pulp filters: Less Pulp and Lots of Pulp. We can control how much pulp we want in our juices and I love this option because if I want to make pasta, I’m going for the Lots of Pulp filter.
The recipe guide for this Ninja doesn’t include any tomato recipes but it includes some nice juice recipes, a kale pulp pesto, a recipe for pulp pancakes, and one for minestrone soup.
Someone mentioned that this Ninja masticating juice is a smaller, electrical-powered version of their manual tomato strainer.
Well, I still think that a strainer is a better option if we want to go through hundreds of pounds for canning but I get the point.
Where to Buy?
5. Omra Spremy Electric Tomato Strainer
The most expensive recommendation is this electric tomato strainer. The price around $300 is significant and I don’t see many people having a justification for wanting to spend so much on an electric tomato strainer.
However, there might be some of you who might find it useful so let’s see what exactly it is capable of doing for us.
What is the most important characteristic is that the Omra Spremy Electric Tomato Strainer can process up to 350 pounds of tomatoes in an hour.
Thus, it can be great for people who grow their own tomatoes in almonds industrial capacities. I can see that situation justifying the price.
Of course, we barely have to do any work. Just use the pusher.
You can check out this YouTube video if you want to see how it works.
However, you’ll also notice that this is a big appliance, like a big meat grinder. If you live in a place that doesn’t have some serious storage space, that won’t do.
The hopper and screen are made of stainless steel.
It includes: milling attachment, motor, stainless steel hopper, plastic sauce tray, nylon plunger, nylon auger, stainless steel perforated screen and instruction manual.
Where to Buy?
6. OXO Good Grips Food Mill
For my last recommendation, I have a product that doesn’t belong to either category.
It basically looks like a big stainless steel colander.
But it also includes a hand crank with a round plate that covers the bottom of the strainer.
When we turn the crank, only the pulp passes through but the seeds and the peels are stopped by the strainer.
The round metal plate crushes the fruits.
So we have to place this food mill that looks like a strainer over a container, bowl, colander, etc.
I like that it’s made of stainless steel with 3 stainless steel grinding discs for preparing foods of fine, medium, and coarse textures.
It has a 2.3 quart capacity so it’s fairly small.
Of course, these types of food mills can be suitable if we’re trying to process a few pounds for some pasta or some other dishes but they’re certainly not good enough for canning big quantities of tomatoes.
The OXO Good Grips Food Mill is also not a juicer. As the name implies, it’s a food mill that is used for preparing food dishes, not drinks.
Where to Buy?
Well, the OXO Good Grips Food Mill is certainly not my favorite pick as the best juicer for tomatoes but I can see that it can have its uses so I thought that there might be some of you who would be interested to discover that such a product exists.